Carol Coronado: A Mother’s Struggle With Postpartum Psychosis

Carol Coronado and one of her daughters (Facebook)

TW: graphic details of violence and murder.

Lindsay Clancy’s case continues to stay in news circulation, as her case just had a hearing Nov. 2, 2026 pertaining to double jeopardy, a gag order, and the holdout juror. The next hearing has been scheduled for 9 a.m. on Nov. 16 when they will discuss the pending motions and may set a trial date.

Despite the continued attention on Clancy’s case, there is still little discussion around the matter at hand: postpartum mood disorders and psychosis.

This is yet another opportunity of many that we have been given to discuss maternal mental health, and we have fumbled it, again. Clancy’s case is not unique and to give some perspective to her trial, we have another case from over a decade ago with shocking similarities.

Carol Coronado and Her Lost Battle to Postpartum Psychosis

Carol Coronado was a mother of three young girls living with her husband, Rudy, in Torrance, CA.

On the morning of May 20, 2014, she left her mother a series of frantic voicemails, begging her to call her back because she was tired, hungry, and “things are getting weird around here.”

Carol’s mother eventually showed up to the house in the afternoon, and walked in to find her grandchildren’s bodies lined up on the bed, lifeless, in order of age: Sophia, 2, Yazmine, 1, and Xenia, 3 months old (Mother Convicted of Killing, 2016).

Carol was holding a knife, lying still on the bed. Her mother claims to have taken the knife out of Carol’s hands and ran outside, alerting Carol’s husband to what had happened. When they returned, Carol took a different knife and plunged it into her own chest (Rylah, 2015).

Carol was quickly taken to the hospital for her wounds, then jail, where Dr. Torang Sepah, psychiatrist, saw her as a patient, and stated, “The diagnosis that I gave her, in layman’s terms, was postpartum psychosis” (How Postpartum Psychosis Transformed a Loving Mother, 2025).

Postpartum Mood Disorders & The Court

Postpartum mood disorders are serious disorders that can develop suddenly at any time from pregnancy to within the first year after childbirth, and can include depression, as well as psychosis in extreme cases (Postpartum Depression, 2026).

Carol was described as nearly catatonic and unlike herself in the days leading up to and after the event. Her state was described as disheveled and unhealthy. While in jail days after the murders, she recognized that she had a scar from stabbing herself, but could not remember doing it.

“It’s common for people not to remember what happened during a psychotic episode,” said Dr. Sepah. “Instead of going A, B, C, they’re going A, D, G” (Rylah, 2015).

Carol clearly had been struggling for some time and lacking in the mental health care and support she desperately needed.

Despite Dr. Sepah’s diagnosis, on Monday, February 1, 2016, Carol was charged with first degree murder of her three daughters. She begged her family for help leading up to the acts, and yet ultimately was still given three life sentences without the possibility of parole by Judge Ricardo Ocampo (Mother Convicted of Killing, 2016).

Judge Ocampo claimed that, despite testimony from her husband and medical experts, she was sane at the time of the killing, and therefore did not lack criminal responsibility. He agreed that she needed help, but that mental health care would have to be in a state prison for her.

Carol’s lawyer referred to the sentencing and court system’s approach to postpartum struggles as “archaic” (Mother Convicted of Killing, 2016).

Carol Coronado is sentenced to 3 life terms on Monday, Feb. 1, 2016. Photo by Brad Graverson/Daily Breeze

And while the judge’s ruling may be archaic, it was not unique. KQED did an analysis of data on incarcerated women in California and found that more than 100 women at the time were in prison for killing their children.

“Forty percent of these women took their baby’s life before they were a year old” (Dembosky, 2020).

An Archaic Approach to Mother’s Mental Health

The court’s and society’s perspective on mothers’ mental health is, indeed, archaic and based on sexist systems that are long overdue for reform. It is likely that many cases of maternal filicide would be preventable with the right mental health care.

Mothers who murder their children often share many characteristics, including a history of abuse, depression, and some studies have shown high rates of psychosis (Freidman et al, 2005).

Maternal filicide and postpartum depression and psychosis are not new or unknown issues for the US. Studies show that despite advancing progressive social and medical care in other western countries, US healthcare for mothers still falls short.

In 2002, Andrea Yates stood trial for drowning her five children in 2001, and was found guilty. An appeals court overturned the conviction and in 2006, she was found not guilty by reason of insanity.

Lindsay Clancy is now potentially facing her potential second trial for strangling her three young children. It remains to be seen if the Massachusetts Commonwealth will bring the first degree murder charges against her again, or let her plead insanity.

Latarsha Sanders similarly will be standing trial in Massachusetts for a second time for the stabbing of her two sons, allegedly while in a state of schizophrenic-induced psychosis (as opposed to postpartum).

All three stories have made nationwide news, and yet society’s biases towards women in crime seem to stifle any real conversations around mothers’ mental health struggles and how we can help.


Thanks for reading. I have a passion for researching US politics, criminal justice, justice reform, misinformation and disinformation, and correcting the misinfo I discover when I can. If that’s all something you’re into, please consider subscribing.


Sources

Dembosky, A. (2020, February). She killed her children. Can we forgive her? KQED. https://www.kqed.org/news/11797827/postpartum

Freidman, S., Horowitz, S., & Resnick, P. (2005, September). Child Murder by Mothers: A Critical Analysis of theCurrent State of Knowledge and a Research Agenda. American Journal of Psychiatry, 162(9). https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ajp.162.9.1578

Mother convicted of killing 3 daughters sentenced to life in prison. (2016, February 1). NBC Southern California. https://www.nbclosangeles.com/news/local/mother-convicted-of-killing-3-daughters-gets-life-in-prison/2017400/

Postpartum Depression. (2026, March). Portpartum Depression. Cleveland Clinic. https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/9312-postpartum-depression

Real Stories. (2025, August 29). How Postpartum Psychosis Transformed a Loving Mother into a Killer [Video]. YouTube.

Rylah, J. (2015, December 9). Mother who stabbed her 3 daughters found sane at the time of the murders. LAist. https://laist.com/news/mother-murdered-her-three-daughters


Discover more from Justice Sensitivity

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

No Comments Yet

Leave a Reply

Discover more from Justice Sensitivity

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading